研究生: |
林佳慧 Chia-Huei Lin |
---|---|
論文名稱: |
女性性別意識發展與母職實踐歷程之敘說分析 A Narrative Study of Gender Consciousness Development and Motherhood Practice Process in Women |
指導教授: |
田秀蘭
Tien, Hsiu-Lan |
學位類別: |
碩士 Master |
系所名稱: |
教育心理與輔導學系 Department of Educational Psychology and Counseling |
論文出版年: | 2004 |
畢業學年度: | 92 |
語文別: | 中文 |
論文頁數: | 126 |
中文關鍵詞: | 性別意識 、母職 、女性主義 、敘說 |
英文關鍵詞: | gender consciousness, motherhood, feminist, narrative |
論文種類: | 學術論文 |
相關次數: | 點閱:732 下載:219 |
分享至: |
查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報 |
本研究的目的在於瞭解探討女性的性別意識發展歷程、分析女性的母職實踐歷程及歸納女性性別意識發展與母職實踐歷程之交互影響,以及探討相關之社會脈絡。
研究者透過一年半在社區女性主義研究社團中參與觀察為起點,以形成對於性別意識發展及母職實踐的先前理解,在資料收集部分則邀請兩位社經地位背景不同的具有性別意識開展經驗的女性進行深度訪談,再以敘說分析中的整體-內容分析方法進行探究,將研究參與者的生命事件與其呈現之性別意識發展及母職實踐歷程的重要主題依時間順序加以重組整合,以理解性別意識及母職實踐歷程的發展脈絡,並以發展圖呈現其核心主題,並探討兩者之間的互動牽連及社會脈絡下的影響因素。
研究發現:
一、研究參與者A的性別意識發展核心主題為「被動接受/主動形塑」,母職實踐歷程核心主題則為「親密/獨立」,從原先只注意他人的需求與肯定,逐漸邁向尋求自我肯定並覺察自我需求。性別意識發展與母職實踐歷程的關連則為1.母職困境啟動性別意識的發展2.性別意識發展使現代母職的實踐變得可能。
二、研究參與者B的性別意識發展核心主題為「女性認同的失落、追尋與悅納」,母職實踐核心主題則為「假自主/真自主」,從接受父權思想中的男優女劣觀點到對自我及女兒的女性特質的肯定與接納。性別意識發展與母職實踐歷程的交互作用包括1.母職經驗對於B的性別意識發展有啟發性的影響。2.女性性別意識實踐在教育觀念。
三、比較A與B的性別意識發展與母職實踐歷程
(一)A與B的相似性
1.性別意識發展促進對於自我女性性別的認同及悅納、啟發因子皆為與女兒的衝突,並因參與女性團體中的姊妹情誼深化性別意識的覺察。
2.母職實踐歷程中。母職觀念均受到母親的影響、均曾女兒發生具重要意義且導向自我改變的衝突、分離的議題均具有相當的重要性。
3.受到共同社會脈絡的影響,包括傳統性別觀、傳宗接代觀念
(二)A與B的相異性
1.性別意識發展歷程中,A從原先重視他人肯定及他人需要,到對於自我需要的覺察及自我肯定。B則由原先只看到自己,到後來能看到別人。
2.母職實踐歷程中,A從全然犧牲奉獻的母親,到能夠悅納自己也允許孩子獨立;B則是從強調自己的自主需求,到能夠看見孩子的需要,增加自己的彈性。
最後並提出對心理諮商實務工作者的建議、對家庭教育及學校教育的建議、對女性性別意識發展課程或女性意識提升成長團體的建議及對相關研究的建議,以及研究者的反思。
The purposes of this study were to understand: (1)the process of gender consciousness development of women; (2)the motherhood practice of women; (3)the process that gender consciousness and motherhood practice influence to each other; and (4)the social context concerning the development of gender-consciousness and motherhood practice.
The researcher observed and participated in a local feminist study group for one and a half year so as to get a pre-understanding of women’s gender consciousness development and their motherhood practice. In-depth interviews were conducted to collect the narratives of gender consciousness development and motherhood practice of two women who belong to different social and economic status. Then holistic content analysis was adopted to analyze the narratives. The findings were as follows:
1. The core theme of gender-consciousness development of interviewee A is “passive-acceptance/active shaping”. The core theme of motherhood practice of A is “intimate/independence”. The difficulties of motherhood practice initiates the development of gender-consciousness and the development of gender-consciousness benefits modern motherhood practice.
2. The core theme of gender-consciousness development for interviewee B was “loss, searching for, and acceptance of female identity”.The core theme of motherhood practice of B is ‘false-autonomy/true autonomy’. The motherhood practice of B facilitated her gender-consciousness. The development of her gender-consciousness influenced her ideas about gender education toward her daughter.
3. The comparison of A and B
(1) The similarities between A and B
A. Both interviewees reported that the development of gender-consciousness was initiated by the conflicts between them and their daughters. Sisterhood between them and other women promoted their awareness of women’s position. Their development of gender-consciousness facilitated the acceptance and appreciation of female identity.
B. Both interviewees’ concepts of motherhood were largely affected by their mothers. They used to suffer from the conflicts with their daughters, which also led to impressive and meaningful ideas of recreating their motherhood. Separation-attachment issue was important for both.
C. The gender-consciousness and motherhood practice of both were affected by similar social context such as traditional gender norms and the mission of generation.
(2)The differences between A and B
A. In the process of gender-consciousness development, A learned about how to take care of herself and B learned how to take care of others.
B. In the motherhood practice, A learned to see her own needs, and B learned how to listen to her children.
Suggestions for counseling practice, family and school education, gender-consciousness raising courses, and future studies were provided. The author also provided self-reflections in the last chapter.
朱嘉琦(民86):臺灣婦女女性意識發展歷程之研究。國立臺灣師範大學教育心理與輔導研究所碩士論文。未出版。
林昱貞(民89):性別平等教育的實踐:兩位國中女教師的性別意識與實踐經驗。台灣師範大學教育學系,碩士論文。未出版。
邱育芳(民85):婦女社區參與和現代母職的實踐:以主婦聯盟的社區運動為例分析。國立清華大學人類研究所,碩士論文。未出版。
胡幼慧編(民85):質性研究。臺北市:巨流出版社。
孫柯譯(民83):解開母女情結。臺北市:遠流。
高歆怡(民92):女性成長社團學員的女性意識知覺及轉化歷程之研究-以永和社區大學為例。中正大學成人及繼續教育研究所碩士論文。未出版。
張瀞文(民88):參與讀書會之成年女性其母職角色認同與轉換歷程之研究。台灣師範大學社會教育學系,碩士論文。未出版。
畢恆達(民92年9月):女性性別意識形成歷程。2003女性主義學術研討會,清華大學。
郭凱儀(民84):社區工作的價值取向及方法。載於莫泰基、郭凱儀、梁寶霖:香港社區工作-反省與前瞻(60-78頁)。香港:中華書局。
莊永佳(民88):臺灣女性之母職實踐。南華管理學院教育社會學研究所碩士論文。未出版。
陳惠娟、郭丁熒(民87):母職概念的內涵之探討-女性主義觀點。教育研究集刊,41輯,73-101頁。
黃光國譯(民60):自卑與超越。臺北市:志文出版社。
黃凱倫(民80):幼兒與母親依附關係及其社會行為之研究。國立臺灣師範大學家政教育研究所碩士論文。未出版。
楊美惠譯(民81):第二性(原著書名:Le Deuxieme Sexe)。臺北市:志文出版社。
趙淑珠(民86):思考諮商員訓練課程中的性別教育性別意識中立與性別意識敏感。輔導季刊,33卷第1期,1-3頁。
劉惠琴(民89):母女關係的社會建構。應用心理研究,6期。97-130頁
劉惠琴(民91):助人專業與性別實踐。應用心理研究,13期,45-72頁。
蔡麗玲(民87):母職作為女性主義實踐。清華大學社會人類研究所碩士論文。未出版。
蕭蘋、李佳燕(民91):母職的社會建構與解構。婦女與性別研究通訊,63期,10-12頁。
藍佩嘉(民80):母職-消滅女人的制度。當代,62期,84-88頁。
胡幼慧(民87):參與式研究-從研究方法來解決知識權力的不平等。載於嚴祥鸞(主編):危險與祕密-研究倫理(183-225頁)。臺北市:三民書局。
嚴祥鸞(民85):參與觀察法。載於胡幼慧(主編):質性研究(195-221頁)。臺北市:巨流出版社。
臺北市:書局。
Agar, M. & Hobbs, J. R.(1982).Interpreting discourse:Coherence and the analysis of ethnographic interviews.Discourse Processes,5,1-32.
Bowlby, J. (1973).Attachment and Loss : Vol.2. Seperation ,201-210.New York:Basic.S.
Bretherton, I.(1980).Young children in stressful situations:The supporting role of attachment figures and unfamiliar caregivers.In G.V. Coelfo&P.I.Ahmed(Eds.).Up-rooting and development,179-210.New York:Plenum.
Chodorow, N. J.(1977).The reproduction of mothering.張君玫譯(民92):母職的再生產。臺北市:群學出版社。
Conover, P. J.(1988).Feminists and the Gender gap.Journal of Politics,50(4),985-1010.
Downing, N. E. & Roush, K. L.(1985).From passive acceptance to active commitment : A model of feminist identity development for women.The counseling psychologist,13(4),695-709.
Fitzgerald, L. F. & Nutt, R.(1986).The Division 17 principles concerning counseling/psychotherapy of women:Rationale and implementation.The Counselling Psychologist,14,180-216.
Gerson, J. M., & Peiss, K.(1985). Boundaries, negotiation, consciousness: Reconceptualizing gender relations. Social Problems, 32, 317-331
Gordon, T.(1990).Feminist mothers.Houndmills. London:Macmillan Education Ltd.
Gurin, P.& Townsend, A. (1986). Properties of gender identity and their implications for gender consciousness. British Journal of Social Psychology, 25, 139-148.
Jacobs, M.(1995).D.R.Winnicott.于而彥、廖世德譯(民92):溫尼考特。臺北市:生命潛能。
Kriesberg, S.(1992).Transforming power:Domination,empowerment and education.State University of New York Press.
Lieblich, A., Tuval-Mashiach, R. & Zilber, T.(1998).Narrative research.London:Sage.
Moradi, B. & Subich, L. M.(2002) .Perceived sexist events and feminist identity development attitudes:Linls to women’s psychological distress.The Counselling Psychologist,30,44-65.
Moradi, B. & Subich, L. M.(2002).Feminist identity development measures:Comparing the Psychometricsof Three Instruments. The Counseling Psychologist,30(1),66-86.
Oakley, A.(1974):Women’s Work:The housewife,past and present.New York:Pantheon Books.
Rich, A.(1982).Of Woman Born.New York:Norton.
Riessman, C. K.(1993).Narrative analysis.London:Sage.
Riessman, C.K.(1993).Narrative analysis.王勇智、鄧明宇譯(民92):敘說分析。臺北市:五南出版社。
Roseneil, S.(1996)Transgressions and transformations , practicing feminism.London:Routledge.
Stanley, L. & Wise, S.(1993).Breaking out again:Feminist Ontology and Epistemology.NY:Routledge.
Steinem, G.(1992).Revolution from within.羅勒譯(民82):內在革命。台北:正中書局。
Strawbrige, S. & Woolf, R.(1996).Counseling Psychology:A sociology perspective.In R.Woolf&W.Dryden(Eds.),Handbook of Counseling Psychology.CA:Sage.
Tong, R.(1989).Feminism thought-A comprehensive introduction.Boulder:Westview Press.
Van IJzendoorrn, M, H. & Tavecchio, L. W. C.(1987):Attachment in social networks,3-25.Elsevier Science Publisher B.V.
Wilcox, C. (1997). Racial and gender consciousness among African-American women: Sources and consequences. Women and Politics, 17(1), 73-94