研究生: |
唐孝蘭 |
---|---|
論文名稱: |
資源回收價值澄清教學效果之研究~以台北市國中一年級學生為例 |
指導教授: | 葉國樑 |
學位類別: |
碩士 Master |
系所名稱: |
健康促進與衛生教育學系 Department of Health Promotion and Health Education |
論文出版年: | 2001 |
畢業學年度: | 89 |
語文別: | 中文 |
論文頁數: | 187 |
中文關鍵詞: | 資源回收 、價值澄清 |
論文種類: | 學術論文 |
相關次數: | 點閱:178 下載:14 |
分享至: |
查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報 |
本研究之主要目的在於以價值澄清法設計一套關於資源回收的自編教材,探討價值澄清法與傳統教學法之教學效果比較分析,希望能提供一套以價值澄清為導向的資源回收環境教育教學模式,以做為未來九年一貫課程實施推動學校資源回收教育的參考。
本研究共分為三組:即實驗組、對照組、校外對照組。實驗組國一學生接受價值澄清教學介入,對照組及校外對照組國一學生則接受傳統講述法教學。進行教學介入之前一週實施前測,教學介入後於一週內實施後測。
本研究結果歸納如下:
一、近九成的研究對象都有從事資源回收的經驗,其資源回收的知識來源以「電視」的比率最高佔88.7%,其次為「家人」、「師長」。
二、三組後測有╱無意圖者之各信念差異比較:實驗組學生在「態度」上有整體性之顯著差異;對照組在「態度」、「自我效能」、「資源回收認知」、及「環境敏感度」達到整體性之顯著差異;校外對照組則是在「結果評價」及「態度」有整體性之顯著差異。
三、不論是傳統講述教學法或是價值澄清教學法,各組在「結果評價」、「態度」、「自我效能」、「行為意圖」、「資源回收認知」及「環境敏感度」上,後測分數均較前測分數為高,表示此兩種教學方法都有其教學效果。
四、三組所有研究對象資源回收行為意圖的影響情形方面,「結果評價」、「態度」、「自我效能」、「資源回收認知」及「環境敏感度」與行為意圖間均成正相關。外在變項中又以過去一個月內曾配合資源回收工作的學生,對於行為意圖的影響層面較大。
五、以學生上課的參與度、課堂氣氛、學生反應情形來看,價值澄清教學法的教學效果較傳統講述教學為佳,對於上課方式的喜好度,以實驗組學生持正向態度的比率較高。但在教室管理及教學進度控制上,又以傳統講述教學法來得好。
六、價值澄清教學比較能夠激發出學生的思考空間與創造力,傳統講述教學法所帶給學生的刺激則較少,而且使用價值澄清教學對於學生來說,印象較傳統講述教學法來得深刻。
The main purpose of this study was to apply values clarification approach to make the teaching models of resources recycling education, and to explore the differences of the effects between values clarification approach and traditional approach.
The sample was selected from students of junior high schools in Taipei. There were three groups: experimental group with values clarification approach, controlled group with traditional approach, controlled group out of school with traditional approach. In order to explore the different teaching effects, the study gave the students two tests before and after teaching intervention in a week.
The main findings of this study were as follows:
1.Almost ninety percents of students had experiences of resources recycling, and 88.7% of their knowledge was from television, and then family, and teachers.
2.Between recycling intenders and non-intenders of all the students: there were significant differences in attitude of experimental group; there were significant differences in attitude, self-efficacy, resources recycling knowledge, environmental sensitivity of controlled group; there were significant differences in evaluation, attitude of controlled group out of school.
3.There were the positively effects in evaluation, attitude, self-efficacy, recycling intention, resources recycling knowledge, environmental sensitivity between values clarification approach and traditional approach.
4.The evaluation, attitude, self-efficacy, resources recycling knowledge, environmental sensitivity of all the students were significantly positively related to the recycling intention. The variables of having recycling experience in a month could effectively predict the recycling intention of students.
5.The teaching model of values clarification was favorable for students, and made better effects on the atmosphere of classes.
6.The teaching model of values clarification could promote better thinking and creativity of students than the traditional one.
參考文獻:
一、中文文獻
王懋雯(民80)。師範學院學生對環境教育之知識、態度及需求研究。國立台灣師範大學衛生教育研究所碩士論文。
王懋雯(民86)。師範學院學生環境行為影響因素之研究-以台北市立師範學院學生為例。國立台灣師範大學衛生教育研究所博士論文。
方紫薇(民75)。青少年自我統整發展暨價值澄清團體諮商對高一女生自我統整之影響。台灣師大輔導研究所碩士論文。
台北市政府環境保護局(民86)。台北市政府環境保護局年報(85年版)。
台北市政府環境保護局(民90a)。台北市政府環境保護局年報(87年版)。
台北市政府環境保護局(民90b)。台北市政府環境保護局施政報告(90年3月)
台灣省立新竹師範專科學校編印(民76)。價值與教學。
行政院環境保護署(民79)。環保資料彙編第三集-專題演講(一)。
行政院環境保護署(民82)。環保績效民意調查專案研究計畫。
行政院環境保護署(民85a)。環境保護年鑑-中華民國八十四年版。
行政院環境保護署(民85b)。中華民國台灣地區環境資訊-84年版。
行政院環境保護署(民85c)。資源回收四合一計畫。
行政院環境保護署(民88)。八十八年版-環境白皮書。
行政院環境保護署(民90)。環境保護統計資料。
朱森楠(民73)。價值澄清法對國中生價值觀、歸因方式的影響。台灣師大輔導 研究所碩士論文。
李永展(民84)。環境態度與環保行為-理論與實證。台北:胡氏。
李界木(民80)。還我自然。台北市:前衛出版社。
李蕙君(民86)。回饋式資源回收四合一計畫-台灣回收工作的新紀元。台灣經濟研究月刊,20卷,3期,頁82-88。
余坤煌(民81)。價值澄清教學活動對國小學童吸菸知識、態度和吸菸決定影響之研究。台灣師大衛生教育研究所碩士論文。
吳明清(民67):澄清「價值澄清法」的幾個問題。師友月刊,138期,12-17頁。
吳南明、張志誠、薛宏欣(民89):我國資源回收法制之演進與評估。環境工程會刊,11卷,4期,29-36頁。
杜瑞澤(民83):產品環保設計之整合系統研究。大業學報,3(1),103-116。
車參賢(民84)。台北市國中生對資源回收的知識、態度、行為相關研究。國立台灣師範大學衛生教育研究所碩士論文。
周淑玲(民78)。國民中學實施垃圾分類之問題研究。國立台灣師範大學中等教育輔導委員會。
林宜真(民77)。資源回收之經濟分析。國立政治大學財政研究所碩士論文。
林清山(民77)。多變項分析統計法。台北:東華書局。
林清山(民81)。心理與教育統計學。台北:東華書局。
林信安(民80):廢鋁罐回收與再生技術。礦業技術,29(4),278-279。
林德申(民75)。價值澄清法對高中男生公民科教學成效之影響。台灣師大教育研究所碩士論文。
邱花妹等著(民89)。解讀台灣綠色競爭力。天下雜誌出版
邱昭蓉(民82)。都市家庭固體廢棄物的組成對減量分類回收角色之探討。國立台灣大學公共衛生研究所碩士論文。
邱連煌(民67):價值澄清法。今日教育、34期,9-18頁。
沈明慧(民83)。價值澄清團體對國中適應不良學生自我概念、價值觀與道德判斷影響成效之研究。國立高雄師範大學叫育研究所碩士論文。
胡文龍、林香生(1994)。社區工作:理論與實踐。香港:中文大學。
柏雲昌(民86):資源回收再利用政策上路了。經濟前瞻,12卷,6期,頁130-135。
柏雲昌(民89):我國資源回收政策的未來發展方向。環境工程會刊,11卷,4期,21-27頁。
柯惠珍(民87)。台北市國中學生家中資源回收行為意圖及相關因素之研究。國立台灣師範大學衛生教育研究所碩士論文。
高翠霞(民78):環境教育之理念。環境教育季刊,3期,8-11頁。
教育部環境保護小組(民87)。國中學生環境保護認知與資源回收信念行為意圖之關係研究。
教育部(民89)。國民中小學九年一貫課程暫行綱要。
晏涵文(民67):價值觀念與健康教學。健康教育,42期,44-46頁。
袁志晃(民73)。職業價值澄清活動對高一學生職業決策行為影響之實驗研究。彰化師大輔導研究所碩士。
夏林清(民67):價值澄清輔導技巧介紹。張老師月刊,1卷,6期,39-43頁。
張子超(民84):環保教師對新環境典範態度分析。環境教育季刊,26期,37-45頁。
張祖恩、張乃斌(民82)。地方環保單位執行資源回收成效評估及改善方案之規劃。行政院環境保護署研究報告第一四五號。
張美麗(民81):舉手之勞救地球。新環境月刊,74,8-10。
梁明煌(民81):實施自然資源環境教育的方式研討。環境教育,12,21-29。
陳永仁(民85):談我國資源回收近況。能源報導,3-6。
陳永仁、呂文賢、黃揮原、黃基森(民85):我國推動資源回收在利用之現況與策略。工業污染防治,15(3),132-144。
陳芳萍(民84)。價值澄清式法治教學對國中生法治知識與態度影響之實驗研究。國立台灣師範大學公民訓育研究所碩士論文。
陳通(民78):廢鋁罐回收之探討。技術與訓練,14(2),24-33。
陳榮祥(民87)。開發符合STS理念的教材及教學策略之實驗研究-國小五年級自然科。高雄師範大學科學教育研究所碩士論文。
陳桂琁(民77)。價值澄清教學法與講述法在國中一年級女生健康教育安全課上的教學效果比較研究。台灣師大衛生教育研究所碩士論文。
陳國成、江瑞湖(民89)。環境科學概論。大中國圖書公司。
許玉雪、柏雲昌、錢玉蘭(民87)。廢一般物品及容器之回收與再生處理成本調查統計分析。行政院環保署。
許美瑞、周麗端、陳妍穎、江宜倩(民89):國中家政科環境教育教學效果之質性分析。中華家政學刊,29期,1-31頁。
許美瑞、周麗端、薛秀(民90):國民中學家政科環境價值教學效果探討。課程與教學季刊,4卷,1期,21-50頁。
植原彰著、劭明宗譯(民88)。環境教育—就從老師開始吧!。稻田出版社。
程詩瀛(民79):留駐青山綠水從再生紙開始。中國環保,5期,62-67頁。
國立編譯館(民86)。國民中學健康教育教師手冊下冊。
童惠芬(民89):從校園廢棄物談資源回收。北縣教育,32期,79-81頁。
黃建一(民78)。我國國民小學價值教學之研究。復文圖書出版社。
黃建一、余作輝合著(民85)。國民小學道德課程與教學。台北:師大書苑。
黃輝源(民89):廢棄物清理法修正重點及其影響。環境工程會刊,11卷,2期,53-58頁。
雲揚有限公司(民80):使用過的飲料容器回收新趨勢。台灣包裝工業雜誌,32期,66-73頁。
葉國樑(民85):台北市國中學生垃圾分類行為意圖之研究。衛生教育雜誌,16期,1-19頁。
葉國樑(民75)。師大B型肝炎學生衛生教育計劃研究-同輩輔導與傳統教學之實際效果。台灣師大衛生教育研究所碩士論文。
葉國樑(民86)。城鄉地區國中學生資源回收行為意圖比較研究。台北:師大書苑。
葉國樑、柯惠珍(民88):台北市國中一年級學生環境保護認知與資源回收信念行為意圖之關係研究。衛生教育學報,12期,49-74頁。
葉國樑(民89):國民中學校園資源回收。北縣教育,32期,71-75頁。
葉國樑、趙宏邦、唐貺怡(民89):台北地區居民資源回收信念與行為意圖研究。衛生教育學報,13期,53-72頁。
葉國樑(民90):國民中學健康教育科環境價值教學模式之學習效果研究。衛生教育學報,15期。
趙宏邦(民88)。台北市社區民眾資源回收信念與行為意圖研究。國立台灣師範大學衛生教育研究所碩士論文。
劉志成(民82)。國民環保手冊。台北市:月旦出版有限公司。
劉興郁(民70):價值澄清法在健康教學中的應用。衛生教育雜誌,2期,42-51頁。
歐用生、林瑞欽譯(民75)。價值澄清法。復文圖書出版社。
歐滄和(民71):價值澄清法的理論與實施。輔導月刊,18卷,7.8期合刊,1-9頁。
蔡佳伶(民83)。師範學院學生紙張回收行為意圖研究。國立台灣師範大學衛生教育研究所碩士論文。
羅月鳳(民82)。資源回收指南。台北市:台灣地球日出版社。
蘇聰敏(民83)。開放經濟體系下之廢紙回收的最適環境政策。國立台灣清華大學經濟研究所碩士論文。
謝明昆(民74):價值教學在國小教育上之應用。國教世紀,20卷,10期,25-29頁。
二、英文文獻
Ajzen,I. & Fishbein,M.(1980) Understanding attitudes and predicting social behavior. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice-Hall, Inc.
Arbuthnot,J. & Lingg,S.(1975) A comparison of French and American environment behaviors, and knowledge and attitudes. International Journal of Psychology, 10,275-284.
Arbuthnot,J.(1974) Environmental knowledge and recycling behavior as a function of attitudes and personality characteristics. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,1,119-121.
Arbuthnot,J.(1977) The roles of attitudinal and personality variables in the prediction of environmental behavior and knowledge. Environment and Behavior, 9(2),217-232.
Bachman,W. & Katzev,R. (1982) The effects of noncontingent free bus tickets and personal commitment on urban bus ridership. Transportation Research ,16a ,103-108.
Bandura,A.(1977).Social learning theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice hall.
Bandura,A.(1980).Gauging the relationship between self-efficacy judgment and action. Cognitive Therapy and Research,4,263-268.
Bandura,A.(1982). Self-efficacy mechanism in human agency. American Psychologist,37,122-147.
Bandura,A.(1986). Social foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive theory. Englewood cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall Inc.
Bentler,J.S. & Speckart,G.(1981) Attitude “cause” Behavior: A structural equation analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 40(2),226-238.
Bloom,B.S.Eds.(1956)Taxonomy of Educational Objectives.David Mckay Company,Inc.New York.
Blum,A.(1981) Students’ knowledge and beliefs concerning environmental issues in four countries. The Journal of Environmental Education,12(3),7-13.
Burn,S.M. & Oskamp,S.(1986) Increasing community recycling with persuasive communication and public commitment. Journal of Applied Social Psychology,16(1),29-41.
Casteel,J.D.,& Stahl,R.J.(1975) Value Clarification in the Classroom:A Primer. Santa Monica,California:Goodyear.
Couch,C.V., Garber,T., & Karpus,L.(1978-79) Response Maintenance and paper recycling. Journal of Environmental Systems,82,127-137.
De Young,R.(1985-86) Encouraging environmentally appropriate behavior: The role of intrinsic motivation. Journal of Environmental Systems, 15,281-292.
De Young,R.(1986) Some psychological aspect of recycling: The structure of conservation satisfactions. Environment and Behavior,18(4),435-449.
De Young,R.(1988-89) Exploring the difference between recyclers and non-recyclers: The role of information. Journal of Environmental Systems,18(4),341-351.
Derksen,L. & Gartrell,J.(1993) The social context of recycling. American Sociological Review,58,432-442.
Dispoto,R.G.(1977) Interrelationships among measures of environmental activity, emotionality, and knowledge. Educational and Psychological Measurement,37,451-459.
Finnie,W.C.(1973) Field experiment in litter control. Environment and Behavior, 5(2),123-144.
Flora,J.A., Maibach,E.W. & Maccoby,N.(1989) The role of mass media across four levels of health promotion intervention. Annual Review of Public Health. Palo Alto, CA: Annual Reviews.
Fredricks,A.J. & Dossett,D.L.(1983) Attitude-behavior relations: A comparison of the Fishbein-Ajzen and the Bentler-Speckart models. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,45(3),501-512.
Geller,E.S., Chaffee,J.L. & Ingram,R.E.(1975) Promoting paper recycling on a university campus. Journal of Environmental Systems,5(1),39-57.
Hamad,C.D., Bettinger,R., Cooper,D. & Semb,G.(1980) Using behavioral procedures to establish an elementary school paper recycling program. Journal of Environmental Systems,10(2),149-156.
Heberlein,T.A.(1981) Environmental attitude. Zeitschrift for Umweltpolitik, 2,241-270.
Heslop,L., Moran & Cousinean (1981) Consciousness in energy conservation behavior: An exploratory study. Journal of Consumer Research,8(3), 299-305.
Hines,J.M., Hungerford,H.R. & Tomera,A.N.(1987) Analysis and synthesis of research on responsible environmental behavior: A meta-analysis. Journal of Environmental Education,18(2),1-8.
〝Household Waste Threatening Environment; Recycling Helps Ease Disposal Problem.〞(1989) Gallup Report,290,30-36。
Humphrey,C.R., Bord,R.J., Hammond,M.M. & Mann,S.H.(1977) Attitudes and conditions for cooperation in a paper recycling program. Environment and Behavior,9(1),107-124.
Humphrey,C.R., Harris,G.R. & Mann,S.H.(1978-79) Sociological aspects of waste paper recovery. Journal of Environmental System,8(2),111-126.
Iozzi,I.A.(1989) What research says to the education. Part One: Environmental Education. The Journal of Environmental Education,20 (3),3-9.
Jacobs,H.E. & Bailey,J.S.(1982-83) Evaluating participation in a residential recycling program. Journal of Environmental Systems, 12(2),141-151.
Jacobs,H.E., Bailey,J.S. & Crews,J.I.(1984) Development and analysis of a community-based resource recovery program. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis,17,127-145.
Jones,R.E.(1989-90) Understanding paper recycling in an institutionally supportive setting: An application of the theory of reasoned action. Journal of Environmental Systems,19(4),307-324.
Jones,R.E.(1990) Understanding paper recycling. Doctoral dissertation, Washington State University.
Kasen,S., Vaughan,R.D., & Walter,H.J.(1992) Self-efficacy for AIDS preventive behaviors among Tenth Grade students. Health Education Quarterly, 19(2),187-202.
Katzev,R. & Pardini,A.(1987-88) The comparative effectiveness of reward and commitment in motivating community recycling. Journal of Environmental System,17,93-113.
Katzev,R.D. & Johnson,T.R.(1983) A social-psychological analysis of residential electricity consumption: The impact of minimal justification techniques. Journal of Ecological Psychology,3,267-284.
Kingery,P.M.(1990) Self-efficacy and self-monitoring of selected exercise and eating behavior of college students. Healthy Education,21(1),26-29.
Kingery,P.M., & Glasgow,R.E.(1989) Self-efficacy and outcome Expectations in the self-regulation of non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus. Health Education, 20(7),13-19.
Krejcie,R.V., & Morgan,P.W.(1970) Determing sample size for research activities. Educational and Psychological Measurement,30,607-610.
Ladd,A.E.(1990) The solid waste crisis and support for recycling: A research note. Sociological Spectrum,10,469-484.
Lansana,F.M.(1992) Distinguishing potential recyclers from nonrecycles: A basis for developing recycling strategies. Journal of Environmental Educaiotn, 23(2),16-23.
Lee,Y.J. & De Young,R.(1994) Intrinsic satisfaction derived from office recycling behavior: A case study in Taiwan. Social Indicators Research,31,63-76.
Lefebvre,R.C. & Flora,J.A.(1988).Social marketing and public health intervention. Health Education Quarterly,15,299-315.
Leonard-Barton,D.(1981) Voluntary Simplicity lifestyles and energy conservation. Journal of Consumer Research,8,243-252.
Luyben,P.D. & Bailey,I.(1979) Newspaper recycling: The effects of rewards and proximity of containers. Environmental and Behavior,11(4),539-557.
Luyben,P.D. & Cummings,S.(1981-82) Motivating beverage container recycling on a college campus. Journal of Environmental Systems, 11(3),235-245.
Maloney,M.P., Ward,M.P. & Braucht,G.N.(1975) A revised scale for the measurement of ecologic attitudes and knowledge. American Psychologist,30,787-790.
Marcinkowski,T.J.(1988) An analysis of correlates and predictor of responsible environmental behavior. Dissertation Abstract International,49(12),3677-A.
McCaul,K.D., & Kopp,J.T.(1982) Effects of goal setting and commitment on increasing metal recycling. Journal of Applied Psychology,67(3), 377-379.
McGuinness,J., Jones,A.P. & S.G.(1977) Attitudinal correlates of recycling behavior. Journal of Applied Psychology,62(4),376-384.
Myers,R.E. & Ross,E.S.(1994) Modeling adherence to colorectal cancer screening. Preventive Medicine,1(23),142-151.
Nielsen,J.M. & Ellington,B.L. (1983) “Social processes and resource conservation: A case study in low technology recycling,” in N.R. Feimer and E.S. Geller(eds.) Environmental Psychology: Directions and Perspectives, New York: McGrar-Hill.
Oskamp,S., Harrington,M.J., Edward,T.C., Sherwood,D.L., Okuda,S.M. & Swanson,D.C.(1991) Factors influencing household recycling behavior. Environment and Behavior,23(4),494-519.
Pallak,M. & Cummings,N.(1976) Commitment and voluntary energy conservation. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,2,27-31.
Pardini,A. & Katzev,R.(1983-84) The effects of strength of commitment on newspaper recycling. Journal of Environmental System,13,245-254.
Reid,D.H., Luyben,P.D., Rawers,R,J. & Bailey,J.S.(1976) Newspaper recycling behavior: The effects of prompting and proximity of containers. Environment and Behavior,8(3),471-478.
Rosenstock,I.M., Strecher,V.J. & Becker,M.H.(1988) Social Learning Theory and The Health Belief Model. Health Education Quarterly,15(2),175-183.
Roth,R.E.&Helgeson,S.L.(1992) A review of research related to environmental education.Columbus,OH:ERIC/SMEAC.ED068359.
Sia,A., Hungerford,H., Tomera,A.(1985-86) Selected predictors of responsible environmental behavior: An analysis. Journal of Environmental Education,17(2),31-40.
Simmons,D.A. & Widmar,R.(1990) Motivations and barriers to recycling: Toward a strategy for public education. Journal of Environmental Educaiton,22(1),13-18.
Slater,M.D.(1989) Social influences and cognitive control as predictors of self-efficacy and eating behavior. Cognitive Therapy Research,13(3),231-245.
Steininger & Voegtlin (1976) Attitude bases of recycling. The Journal of Social Psychology,100,155-156.
Strecher,V.J., Devellis,B.M., Becker,M.H. & Rosenstock,I.m.(1986) The role of self-efficacy in achieving health behavior change. Health Education Quarterly,13(1),73-91.
Vining,J. & Ebreo,A.(1990) What makes a recycler? A comparison of recyclers and nonrecyclers. Environment and Behavior,22(1),55-73.
Vries,H., V.J., Devellis,B.M. & Kuhlman,P.(1988).Self-efficacy: the third factor besides attitude and subjective norm as a predictor of behavioral intentions. Health Education Research,3,273-282.
Wang,T.H. & Katzev,R.D.(1990) Group commitment and resource conservation: Two field experiments on promoting recycling, Journal of Applied Social Psychology,20(4),265-275.
Ward,S.E.(1990) Characterizing Adolescent Eating Behaviors with Bandura’s Social Learning Theory. University of Virginia. Unpublished dissertation.
Webster,F.E.(1975) Determining the characteristics of the socially conscious consumer. Journal of Consumer Research,2,188-196.
Weigel,R.H.(1985) Ecological attitudes and actions. In Gray, D.B.(Ed.) Ecological beliefs and behaviors: Assessment and Change, Westport, C.N.: Greenwood Press.
Williams,S.L. & Watson,N.(1985) Perceived self-efficacy as cognitive determinates of acrophobia behavior. Behavior Therapy,16,136-146.
Witmer,J.F. & Geller,E.S.(1976) Facilitating paper recycling: Effect of prompts, raffles, and contests. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis,9,315-322.