研究生: |
陳逸祥 |
---|---|
論文名稱: |
單一性別選訓名額措施對台灣中學女生參加化學奧林匹亞競賽表現的研究 |
指導教授: | 方泰山 |
學位類別: |
碩士 Master |
系所名稱: |
化學系 Department of Chemistry |
論文出版年: | 2012 |
畢業學年度: | 100 |
語文別: | 中文 |
論文頁數: | 96 |
中文關鍵詞: | 國際化學奧林匹亞競賽 、化學資優教育 、性別差異 、學習成就 |
英文關鍵詞: | International Chemistry Olympia, Chemical gifted education, Gender differences, Learning achievement |
論文種類: | 學術論文 |
相關次數: | 點閱:159 下載:14 |
分享至: |
查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報 |
本研究根據第40 (2008)-43 (2011)屆臺灣化學奧林匹亞選訓過
程:(一) 初選報名及實際參與人數,(二) 參賽學生成績,(三) 第43
屆臺灣化奧參賽選手問卷回函等三種資料,經過統計與分析程序來探
討。自2010 年首次試辦“單一性別名額措施”對於臺灣化奧報名與
選訓過程的影響並檢視是否達到當初預期的兩個目標: (一) 該措施
的實施,可否增加女性學生的報名參與意願;(二) 該措施可否幫助化
奧選訓團隊篩選出具備實力代表臺灣出賽的女性參賽選手與其成效。
研究結果顯示: (一) 經由報名人數的統計與分析顯示“單一性
別名額措施”的 施行,只在短時間內引起女性學生的注意;(二) 根
據選訓營入選及實際參與名單顯示,即使有保障定額錄取的機制,仍
有男女性學生放棄參與資格。雖然女性學生放棄資格的比例較男性學
生為低;(三) 首次施辦“單一性別名額措施”的第42 屆臺灣化奧選
訓未能篩選出具化學潛能的女性學生,但卻能迅速地在隔年的第43
屆篩選出兩位實力堅強的女性學生成為參賽選手,顯示可在選訓名額
措施下幫助發展女學生的化學潛能;(四) 根據第43 屆參賽選手的觀
點,該措施的施行確實不但可以鼓舞一些實力堅強的女性學生參與報
名,且對於實力堅強的男性學生並不會降低報名參與的意願。
總結上述研究結果,得知“單一性別名額措施”的施行雖然只能
於短期內激起女性學生的興趣而增加報名參與的意願,卻能在臺灣化
奧選訓過程中發掘出女性學生的化學潛能,甚至篩選出代表臺灣參加
國際化學奧林匹亞競賽參賽選手。這不僅僅顯示該措施實現了設立的
初衷,也說明了只要有措施層面上的幫助,雖屬少數的女性學生於化
學科目上的成就表現也不會輸給男性學生,甚至能表現得更加亮眼,
不過需注意男學生於競賽上的公平性與被保障女學生的化學能力在
現實價值觀的社會,是否能安穩應付更為艱深的國際水準化學課程,
仍有待觀察。為符合兩性平權的期待,建議複選選拔訓練營的單一性
別保障名額能更進一步提升至同決選的1/3 總名額。
This study is based on the 40th (2008)-43rd (2011) IChOs of the 4 runs in Taiwan Chemistry Olympiad selection and training program data: (1) primary application and the actual number of participants for the 1st run examination, (2) participating students achievement, and (3) 43rd International Chemistry Olympiad contestants’ questionnaire reply letter etc., through statistics and analysis to examine the first implementation in 2010 of the act " single-sex quotas " in the Selection and Training program of Taiwanese team to the International Chemistry Olympiad in achieving the two original intended targets: (1) the passion of female students participation, and (2) the more female contestants in the Taiwanese Team to IChO. Results of this study are as follows:
1. Based on primary exam (1st run) enrollment statistics and
analysis, “single-sex quotas "act draws the attention of female
students only for a short period.
2. According to the 2nd and 3rd runs of the selection and study
camps, even if there is a " single-sex quotas "act, there were
still 10~20% students giving up eligibility. It is a pity that
although the proportion of female students to give up this
opportunity is lowers than that of the male students; there are
still female students to surrender in these rare quotas.
3. No female student was selected in the first implementation
of the act “single-sex quotas " as the Taiwanese contestants
in 42nd IChO, but half of the female-contestants were in the
Taiwanese team and all got metals as well of the next 2011
43rd IChO.
4. According to the survey of the 4 43rd contestants , "
single-sex quotas "act can encourage and motivate only
relatively small number of confidant and positive attitude
female students toward chemistry, and male students with
confidence are still enrolled in and will not reduce.
In summary, we learned that although " single-sex quotas " act can only in the short term promote the interest and attention of female students in the field of Chemistry, this act does help in finding and digging out the potential of female-student and realized in the IChO events. This act is not only achieve the 2 original targets, but also shows that the female-student has a more mature and steady sate in the experimental and life(organic) science as well, so long as the selection and study program are based on fairness assessments and ability in the Chemistry field. It is suggested that the female-quotas of the 2nd run study-camp can be increased from the current 1/5 to 1/3 as that of the final 3rd run.
壹、中文部分:
方泰山、廖焜熙(1993)。國際化學奧林匹亞 -化學資優青年的競技
場- 。國際化學奧林匹亞(I),9-11。國立台灣師範大學科學教育中心編印。
方泰山(2011)。教育部第43 屆2011 土耳其安卡拉國際化學奧林匹亞
競賽總報告書(上)。
宋秀芬 (2008)。趣味科學活動對國中生「科學態度」與「對科學的態度」之研究。國立臺灣師範大學化學研究所碩士論文。
吳道愉(2012)。我國參予國際科學奧林匹亞競賽選手專業發展的追蹤
研究:以1991~1996 年參賽選手為對象。國立臺灣師範大學特殊教育學系博士論文。
吳淑敏 (2003)。傑出女性科學家生涯發展歷程及其成功因素之探討。
國立臺灣師範大學特殊教育系研究所博士論文。
吳嘉麗 (2011)。女科技人為什麼需要結社。民國一○○年十二月十五號科技報導,科學教育,第19 版。
維基百科(2011)。國際化學奧林匹克競賽。
取自:http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/国际化学奥林匹克竞赛
黃幸美(1995)。數理與科學教育的性別差異之探討。婦女與兩性學刊,566 期,95-135。
劉哲淵(2000)。國際化學奧林匹亞競賽(IChO)原命題建構與我國學生
實作風格之研究。國立臺灣師範大學化學研究所碩士論文。
貳、英文部分:
Catherine Hi l l;Christianne Corbett;Andresse St. Rose (2007).
Why So Few? Women in Science, Technology, Engineering, and
Mathematics. From
http://www.aauw.org/learn/research/whysofew.cfm
Diane F. Halpern, 1 *† Lise Eliot, 2 Rebecca S. Bigler, 3 Richard A. Fabes, 4
Laura D. Hanish, 4Janet Hyde, 5 Lynn S. Liben, 6 Carol LynnMartin.(2011)
The Pseudoscience of Single-Sex Schooling. Science 23 September 2011:
Vol. 333no. 6050 pp. 1706-1707. From
http://www.sciencemag.org/content/333/6050/1706
International Chemistry Olympiad ICHO International Information Center.
From
http://www.iuventa.sk/en/Subpages/ICHO/ICHO-REGULATIONS.alej
Martha Irvine(2011). Women Making Slow, Sure Strides In
Science, Math. From
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/10/22/women-science_n_1
026411.html
Wilson, K ; Kueter, N ; Dennis, G ; Nulsen, A ; Verdon, M (2007)
Addressing gender disparity in the Physics National Qualifying Exam for
58
the Australian Science Olympiads. Teaching Science – the Journal of the
Australian Science Teachers Association, 53(1), 24-29.
Retrieved December 1, 2009. From
http://trove.nla.gov.au/work/153064774